REVIEWS of The CWT Draft

[Rodger Thorm <dqn@earthlink.net>]

Would those of you who are actively evaluating the proposed draft of the Combined Weapons Table, or who plan to comment on it before December 15 (the end of the evaluation period) please let me know (email me directly, if you would) so I know who is looking at it and is interested in participating in the feedback.  That way, too, I know what the base for consensus is.

Is 30 days too short a period?

As I wrote the process up, I didn't allow for any adjustments.  But David has brought up a number of points, and at least some of them may lead to changes that are more than typographic.  Should that irregularity be waived, or should we have another evaluation period once we have a first round of comments on this draft?

I was probably too hasty in nominating the draft for inclusion, since there was not really any time for comment.  I think I would be more inclined to sort out these last bits, and then have a revised draft for final approval.


  --Rodger Thorm